\uD83C\uDF08 Options considered
Zonar (MyView) | Here Comes the Bus | Versatrans (Mystop) | |
---|---|---|---|
Sales Contact | Michael Kilian | David Payne | Liz Waldron |
Show Bus Stop Time/Location Data to Parents | No
| Yes Data is pulled nightly from Versatrans
| Yes
|
Versatrans Bus Stop Data Sync | None | Nightly | Measured in minutes |
GPS Hardware Considerations | Uses existing Zonar hardware and is obviously okay with that.
| Compatiable with existing Zonar hardware, however would prefer “Sinnophia” hardware. Possibly better updates and more reliability with their preferred GPS units.
| Compatiable with existing Zonar hardware, however would prefer their hardware (need to get name). Possibly better updates and more reliability with their preferred GPS units.
|
Show Map with Bus Location Real Time | Yes | Yes | Yes |
GeoFence |
|
|
|
Parent Account/Sign up Process | Parents need to self-sign up which route they are watching.
Need Global code: (Recommend to change yearly) Parents need to know what bus/route (aka KEY) their student runs on. Student ID, route, first, last name. Repeat steps for multiple kids.
| Parents use a district code, student ID, and child last name to see their child on the app. Aaron Souza Check into how HCTB handles how parents add multiple kids, same process?
| Parent Accounts: Student ID and password (birthdate usually). To “link” to view other students on the app, parents use the family ID field from Versatrans to see all 3 students.
|
Substitute Bus Info to Parents? | Has the ability to temporarily assign a 24 hour bus substitute, so Bus 15 breaks down and bus 30 replaces it for the day, for some or all routes, so parents are watching the correct bus automatically | Has a substitute bus function, dispatchers go into mybusstop and change bus 38 to 45 Can actually split by bus stops (like bus 12 picking up back half route for bus 35) “Stop level substitution” | Has a substitute bus function, via “OnScreen”. Set bus as sub for one route or all routes. |
Mass Notifications | Has the ability to mass push notification to smartphone app users about bus delays. Seems relatively straight forward. | Has the ability to mass push notification to smartphone app users about bus delays. Seems relatively straight forward. | Has the ability to mass push notification to smartphone app users about bus delays. Seems relatively straight forward. |
Piloting Software? |
| Unknown
|
|
Pros and cons |
|
💣 Split family management seems very difficult to possibly impossible since each student can have just one “family ID” field, coming from versatrans.
| |
Estimated cost | $10.50/bus/month 70 buses ~ $8,800 using existing Zonar GPS 3 Year Cost: ~$26,000 | Unknown
| ~ $21,000 year 1 ~ $3,000 year 2 3 Year Cost: ~ $27,000 |
Follow Up Issues | 30 minute after bell time.
Response: If bell time is 8:00 AM, the bus is tracked from 6:00 AM to 8:30 AM In the afternoon, for ‘from-school’ trips, the time window starts 30 minutes prior to school closing time and extends for two hours thereafter. So, if the school closes at 3:00 PM, the bus is tracked from 2:30 PM to 5:00 PM. | Can we turn off mystop messaging? Hand drawn maps / roads for new subdivisoins? How does the parent app map know about a new road? | |
References | Aaron Souza Email references for Zonar MyView Positive reference: We began using MyView at the start of this school year. There were some initial issues, but we found they were just things that we would learn as we go. We learned new students don't download automatically, so we had to implement a weekly update to add those new students. We created a QR code that parents could use to download the app and then provided instructions (which are very simple) to set up their student's bus. We have been very happy with it, parents are using it and we have reduced those types of phone calls to almost zero. I would certainly recommend it if you are already using Zonar. We decided to only use MyView and not ZPass. That may come later. |
Talked to director, they are stuck in a 5 year deal with them. Starting to work now, but didn’t work first few weeks of school. | Requested References
|
Summary | So far the leading candidate, from initial team (Aaron,Mary,Pam). |
🚏 Other Solutions Not Compatible
StopFinder application requires the use of Transfinder (a competitor to Versatrans)
Ride360 application uses Traversa (Versatrans Online 2.0)
✅ Action items
Task report
Looking good, no incomplete tasks.